Organization

/

Insurance

Property and Casualty Insurance

Offering you the unique coverage your ministry needs.

Access MyCoverage Center™Request a Quote

What We Offer

Property Insurance

Cover your buildings, property and belongings. If your ministry is damaged, destroyed or the victim of theft, this policy can help lessen financial burdens resulting from a loss.

Liability and Excess Liability Insurance

Guard your ministry, employees, leaders and volunteers from lawsuits, liabilities and losses. Also ensure that what makes your ministry unique is protected with excess liability insurance.

Commercial Auto

Provide coverage for people’s injuries and your ministry’s vehicles in the event of an accident. A commercial auto policy can help lessen financial burdens arising from vehicle liabilities, collisions, personal injury and more.

Workers' Compensation

Employee Benefits
Help employees who suffer from a work-related injury or illness by offering workers’ compensation to help pay for medical, disability, rehabilitation and, in rare instances, expenses associated with death on the job.

Employer’s Liability
Protect your ministry from financial loss in the event that an employee files a suit for a work-related injury or illness.

Mission Travel

Protect your mission teams whether they are going a few miles down the road or halfway around the world.

What People Are Saying About GuideStone

Dr. Bobby Hall, President, Wayland Baptist University
“
In today’s turbulent higher education space, we needed more protection at lower rates. We reviewed a number of industry-leading vendors and ultimately elected GuideStone. With 30% premium savings on $40 million more coverage, better coverage of some liability gaps, stronger cyber coverage and very responsive claims assistance, we have been very pleased with our ministry partnership.”
Dr. Bobby Hall, President, Wayland Baptist University

Dr. Bobby Hall, President
Wayland Baptist University

Doug Grissom, Senior Pastor, Twin Cities Baptist Church
“
We were going to have to close our doors. Property and Casualty Insurance was so high. The quote from GuideStone saved us a little over 60%, but the coverage was comparable - greater in some areas. It was quick, easy and extremely timely for us. GuideStone’s coverage allowed us to keep our doors open.”
Doug Grissom, Senior Pastor, Twin Cities Baptist Church

Doug Grissom, Senior Pastor
Twin Cities Baptist Church

Alan Taylor, Business Administrator, FBC Trussville, Trussville, AL
“
You need somebody you can depend on. You need somebody that’s affordable. You need somebody you can trust. You need somebody that you can call and get a response. GuideStone has exceeded all of those things for us. Insurance is not always an easy subject. They make it so easy.”
Alan Taylor, Business Administrator, FBC Trussville, Trussville, AL

Alan Taylor, Business Administrator
FBC Trussville, Trussville, Alabama

Greg Bath, Executive Pastor, Trinity Baptist Church
“
When Hurricane Laura devastated our community, they [GuideStone] were immediately on our campus. I am always able to rest in the [assurance] that GuideStone promised to be here for us. . .We have a team behind us who are dedicated to championing our efforts to rebuild not just our facilities but our lives.”
Greg Bath, Executive Pastor, Trinity Baptist Church

Greg Bath, Executive Pastor
Trinity Baptist Church

Risk Management Resources

Churches and ministry organizations like yours face a growing and overwhelming number of risks. Great protection goes beyond coverages — it also includes prevention. We designed these resources to empower and equip your ministry toward Christ-centered well-being. Read about developing policies and procedures, abuse prevention, safety and security, disaster preparation and response, overall risk management and more.

See All
Image of padlock and security graphics overlaying image of man at desk with laptop
Article • 2/7/2024
12 Data Security Management Tips to Keep Sensitive Information Out of the Wrong Hands
Is sensitive personal and financial data safe at your church? Follow 12 data security tips to help keep your data out of the wrong hands.
Image of person inspecting row of fire extinguishers with pen and paper in hand.
Article • 1/5/2024
Facility Maintenance Checklist – Use a Preventive Schedule to Help Avoid Costly Issues
Regular inspection of pipes, rooftops, wiring and more can reveal issues before they become costly problems. Follow a facility maintenance checklist for prevention.
Two employees, gesturing as if working through a dispute.
Article • 2/7/2024
Is your ministry protected against 3 common employee liability disputes?
Sexual harassment, an unlawful termination or an error in benefits administration can lead to employee liability lawsuits. Discover ways to protect your ministry.

Meet the Team

We’re focused on serving those who serve the Lord — that’s what sets our agents apart. They’re not only ministry insurance experts — they’re ministry servants. From helping you craft the right property and liability program to counseling you on risk management, they’re committed to your ministry’s well-being.

Find Your Agent

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the real claims our churches are seeing?

Based on recent claims data, the top claims our churches are seeing include wind damage, fire damage, hail damage, water damage, workers’ compensation, sexual acts liability and non-owned/hired car liability. We want to help you be proactive in protecting your ministry and those you serve. Get a quote today.

What issues should church board members be aware of?

The governing board of a church plays a key role in moving the ministry toward its goals. When you accept a position on the church board, you agree to guide the church and put its interests before your own. As a result, you will be held to a higher standard of accountability than your neighbors in the congregation. As you make decisions affecting the life of the ministry, be sure you understand the top 10 things church board members should know about their ministry.

What should our church do when a background check turns up a criminal record?

A good general rule is to use the same criteria followed by the local public school system. If the public school system is prohibited from employing the candidate, then your ministry would do well to avoid employing or involving the candidate. You can find out what criteria are used by contacting your local public school system directly or by enlisting the help of an attorney. Learn more.

How does your policy cover special events and mission trips?

Separate policies can be purchased for both special events and mission trip coverage. When an accident occurs during church, school or camp activities, accident insurance plans will help by providing coverage for medical expenses associated with accidental injuries, with deductibles as low as $0. And regardless of where your mission takes you, travel insurance is essential. Brotherhood Mutual has allied with Fly For Good® to bring mission travelers the Faith Ventures® card, an affordable travel medical insurance option that comes with single- or multi-trip plans for foreign and domestic short-term mission travel.

See all FAQs

Request More Information

Thank you for your interest in the GuideStone Property & Casualty Program. Please complete both the personal and ministry contact information sections, and we will get back to you promptly.

Personal Contact Information

Ministry Contact Information

By submitting this form, I confirm that I have read and agree to the Privacy Statement.


California Residents: By submitting this form, you will be providing Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company® with personal information such as your name, telephone number and job title. Brotherhood Mutual may use this information to respond to your request and provide you with information regarding insurance products and related services. We may also provide this information to an independent agent who may contact you to further discuss your insurance needs. To learn more about how we use your personal information, view our Privacy Notice for California Consumers.


Individual RetirementInsuranceInvestments }
Organization RetirementInsuranceInvestments }
Resources EducationFormsMinisterial Resources CenterSecure 2.0Legal Notices }
About Us Our StoryOur LeadershipNews RoomCareersContact Us }
Mission:Dignity About UsWho We ServeGet InvolvedContact Mission:Dignity }
한국어 Español Prospectus Accessibility Policy Privacy Policy Security GS Rep Login

© 2024 GuideStone®. All Rights Reserved.

Call Toll Free: 1-888-98-GUIDE

Property and liability insurance coverage provided by Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company is subject to conditions, coverage limits, limitations and exclusions. For precise details of coverage, please refer to actual policy forms. These products are only available in states where Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company is licensed and will be written in accordance with company underwriting rules. GuideStone Agency Services® is an appointed agency of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company in Texas, Alabama, Louisiana and Tennessee.

Brotherhood Mutual and the Brotherhood Mutual logo are registered trademarks of Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company and are used with permission by Guidestone.